Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth

Enjoy delicious house-made pizzas, including taco and cream cheese frosting options, at Poor Gary's Pizza of Eveleth. Perfect for takeout, with tasty subs, chicken strips, and a welcoming atmosphere. Call +1 218-744-5508 today!

Welcome to Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth

Taste the Difference.

Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth

Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth invites you to dive into a world of flavor right here in Eveleth, MN. Located at 420 Fayal Rd, this cozy pizza joint has captured the hearts (and stomachs) of locals with its mouthwatering dishes. From the house special pizza to taco pizza and delicious subs, there's something for everyone.

Don't forget to try the unique cream cheese frosting! Whether you're dining in or grabbing a quick takeout, you'll experience a warm and inviting atmosphere. Come for the pizza; stay for the charm of Eveleth.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

420 Fayal Rd, Eveleth, MN 55734, United States

Phone

+1 218-744-5508

About

The Culinary Story

Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth
Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth

Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth has become a staple for pizza lovers in the region. Since its opening, it has focused on delivering quality and taste that locals trust. The heart of the menu lies in its diverse pizza options. The House Special showcases a unique blend of toppings that keeps fans coming back for more. Taco pizza adds an adventurous twist, combining classic pizza elements with bold flavors. The commitment to using quality ingredients shines through in every bite.

Their attention to detail doesn't stop at pizza; subs and appetizers are equally impressive. Offering classics like chicken strips and drummies, this restaurant caters to diverse cravings. What sets Poor Gary's apart is the strong community support and involvement. Regulars often gather for game nights, fostering a vibrant community atmosphere. The friendly staff ensures that each visit feels personal and welcoming. Opening hours are shaped by the community's pulse; peak times often see full capacities, particularly on Friday evenings.

For those looking for quieter moments, visiting during lunch or late evenings ensures a seat and a great meal. Poor Gary's has successfully blended a delicious menu with a sense of community, truly making it a place worth visiting if you're in Eveleth.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-12 AM
  • Monday11 AM-12 AM
  • Tuesday11 AM-12 AM
  • Wednesday11 AM-12 AM
  • Thursday11 AM-12 AM
  • Friday11 AM-1 AM
  • Saturday11 AM-1 AM

Diners at Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth will find a variety of features that make this restaurant stand out. First, the menu boasts a total of 23 delicious options, perfect for everyone in the family. It's well-known for its rich pizza sauce that perfectly complements every slice. The appetizers, including crispy onion rings and creamy cheese curds, make for great starters. Enjoy a lively dining environment perfect for game nights with friends or family, complete with decor that reflects the community spirit of Eveleth. Furthermore, the new owner has brought fresh ideas and energy, making each visit feel special.

Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth

The exterior of Poor Gary's Pizza Of Eveleth catches the eye with its inviting charm and friendly signage. It fits seamlessly into the quaint vibe of Eveleth, drawing in both locals and visitors with its warm colors. Outdoor seating allows diners to enjoy their meals while soaking in the local atmosphere. The overall vibe inside is casual and lively, perfect for family gatherings or a night out with friends. This welcoming environment enhances the overall dining experience and encourages patrons to stay longer and enjoy each others' company.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

I once tried to order a pizza here because I learned about pizza in the Super Mario Bros Super Show and the time I watched it and mario mentioned pizza was my bread with cheese and tomato on it awakening. I swear to god pizza is the best food ever created. I can't stop eating pizza and it's got me kicked out of every pizza party ever. Apparently I'm supposed to "share" MY pizza with all these pizza CASUALS. Later on I tracked down Nyanwolf and Zombiecare and helped the song Don't Touch My Pizza get a following. We even got a skin in the worst roblox game, Forsaken! Then we made them remove it because the only thing they ever did that didn't suck was drop noli and they delayed him with new insanely detailed dev characters. Well I'll tell you I got to this one place and INSTANTLY knew I was a little pizza fan with enough pizza to feed me for my whole life. I started eating here once a week, then once a day, then every meal. The doctor told me I had to stop *only* eat pizza. I disagree but then again I'm starting to have health issues that suspiciously align with but definitely aren't actually from eating so much of it. I'm going to sneak over there without his knowledge tomorrow! I'm so excited already!

F
FlamingBird 7.

Great hidden gem in the quad city area on the Iron Range. Service was quick and friendly and the pizza was fantastic! I got the taco pizza and the crust was light fluffy and crunchy and the toppings were fresh. Great pizza sauce as well. Prices were reasonable. If you're driving through the area this spot is well worth the detour!

G
Gavin B.

The pizzas were perfect. Crisp but soft (?!) crust, the cheese was charred just enough, saucy without being too dangerous. I want these all the time. Should have asked for a side of ranch but they were still delicious without. We also had cheese curds and cinnamon-sugar bites with cream cheese frosting. Not a miss in the meal.

B
Bekki C.

Just wow. My boyfriend and I had been wanting to try Poor Gary's for a while, and we're SO glad we did. We eat A-LOT of pizza, and this is literally our new favorite. No kidding. We drove 65 miles round trip to get take out and had our large House pizza polished off within about 12 minutes. Then, WE DROVE BACK the next day for another pizza. We had to. It was that good. Second pizza was as perfect as the first. Super consistent. Amazing staff. Can't say enough good. Great. Now I want another house pizza.

J
Jennifer W.

The pizza and service was great we had the house special was so good and chicken Alfredo was top notch with apps and they came out fast and good, service was nice and friendly. The aesthetic was good overall. I enjoyed it a ton.

R
Rusty S.

The food is great, especially the pizza! The staff is friendly and welcoming. I live nearly 10 miles out of town & when I order delivery, its always on time and food is fresh and hot.

B
Brenda C.